In a controversial move, Italy has introduced a new law that bans its citizens from seeking surrogacy treatment abroad, even in countries where it is legal. This legislation, which was recently passed by the Senate, makes it a criminal offense for Italians to engage in surrogacy overseas. The penalties are severe, including up to two years in prison and a €1 million fine. This new law extends Italy’s long-standing ban on domestic surrogacy and is sparking significant debate, especially among LGBTQ+ rights advocates.
Previously, Italy’s ban on surrogacy only applied to domestic arrangements. Now, however, Italian citizens who seek surrogacy services in other countries—where the practice is legal—could face criminal prosecution. This move is seen as an attempt to curtail reproductive options for Italian citizens, particularly in countries where surrogacy is well-regulated and safe.
Those who violate the new law could face heavy penalties, including up to two years in prison and fines as steep as €1 million. The law applies not only to individuals who use surrogacy abroad but also to those involved in facilitating such arrangements.
Critics of the law argue that it disproportionately impacts LGBTQ+ couples, particularly same-sex couples. In Italy, same-sex couples face numerous barriers when it comes to reproductive options, with restrictions on both adoption and fertility treatments like IVF. For many LGBTQ+ individuals and couples, international surrogacy has been seen as one of the few viable ways to have biological children. With this new law, these couples now face the risk of criminal charges for exploring these options outside of Italy.
While much of the backlash has focused on the LGBTQ+ community, the law is also expected to affect heterosexual couples who may seek surrogacy abroad. Though surrogacy is less common among heterosexual couples in Italy, those who do choose this route could now face similar legal repercussions.
Legal experts and human rights activists have questioned the law’s alignment with international law, raising concerns about its potential conflicts with established human rights protections. There are fears that the law could set a concerning precedent, particularly in a time when reproductive rights are becoming an increasingly important global issue.
This move has been heavily criticised by international organisations, including LGBTQ+ rights groups and reproductive health advocates, who see it as a setback for family equality. Many view the law as an infringement on personal freedom and an attack on reproductive rights, which could undermine Italy’s reputation on the global stage regarding civil liberties and equality.
The law was introduced by the far-right political party Brothers of Italy, led by Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni. Meloni’s government has been pursuing a conservative agenda, which emphasises traditional family values. The new surrogacy law is part of a broader set of policies aimed at restricting reproductive choices and promoting a particular vision of the family unit.
The law has sparked protests both in Italy and internationally. LGBTQ+ rights groups, legal scholars, and even some heterosexual couples who have used surrogacy are calling the law unjust. Demonstrations have taken place in front of Italy’s Senate, with protestors holding banners that read, “Parents, not criminals.” Opponents of the law argue that it is discriminatory, inhumane, and a direct attack on the reproductive rights of individuals and couples who wish to build their families.
The new surrogacy law in Italy represents a significant shift in the country’s stance on reproductive rights, with profound implications for both LGBTQ+ and heterosexual couples seeking surrogacy. The move has prompted widespread criticism and protests, with many questioning its legality and fairness. As this law begins to be enforced, it’s likely that its impact will continue to be felt not only in Italy but also across the international reproductive rights landscape. For those affected, this is a critical moment to stay informed about their legal options and to continue advocating for reproductive freedoms.
START YOUR JOURNEY